one of my greatest fears in life is becoming a two-dimensional or superficial/shallow person, or simply a person that lacks depth. but recently i’ve been thinking – what does being shallow really mean? how do you define depth? are these two things really all that black and white? i decided to do what i do best when i’m battling thoughts like this: blog about it. (side note: the word superficial is also usually associated with females *cough stereotypical “white girls” cough* and i find it a bit sexist, but i’m not going to go into that because then this post would be way too long.)
let’s talk about shallowness
su·per·fi·cial
adjective
1. appearing to be true or real only until examined more closely.
2. not having or showing any depth of character or understanding.
nobody wants to be called superficial. whenever people catch themselves doing shallow things, they usually try to hide it or deny it or act like they don’t care. but why is that even necessary? i mean yes, we just established that we don’t want to come across as superficial, but seriously. it kind of appalls me because i know of many admirable fashion bloggers or celebrities who are intellectual and “deep” people, but probably also care very much about their social media and style and fame and whatever is popular/mainstream, which are all things that are “shallow.” being superficial is generally thought of as BAD!!! but doing superficial things – like caring about your instagram feed – doesn’t always mean it’s bad. (wait, what????)
some things people generally think of when defining shallowness:
- a person who only cares about materialistic things
- like makeup or clothes
- or how many likes you get on instagram
- as well as follower/friend count
- living your life through social media
- selfies and good filters
- caring more about the aesthetic of something more than the thing itself
- buying a lot of stuff and hauling
- being rich and/or famous (i.e. the kardashians)
- caring about what others think of you, what others are doing, and basically what’s “popular”
- basically anything related to materialism, pop culture, and the mainstream
i’m going to openly admit to being guilty of doing or being one or more of the above things. but that doesn’t mean i’m shallow… does it? just because i care about aesthetics and like to haul/buy things and live on social media and do other “shallow things,” doesn’t mean i lack depth as a person, right? right! (right???) then how and/or why did these ideas come to associate themselves with this concept?
“It is easy to forget how full the world is of people, full to bursting, and each of them imaginable and consistently misimagined.”
– John Green, PAPER TOWNS
i apologize for all these – rhetorical or not – questions, but i’m just trying to wrap my brain around this. i don’t understand why we, as normal human beings, feel the need to stop or defend ourselves for liking the things we like or doing the things we do. i don’t really think any of these things dubbed shallow really change or affect the depth of me as a person. that being said…
what does it mean to have depth?
depth
noun
1. complexity and profundity of thought.
2. extensive and detailed study or knowledge.
this is a term i find difficult to define and one that varies from person to person. we all define and see depth a bit differently. i mostly find it as something (or someone) that has a lot of meaning and a lot of layers, something that could mean one thing but could also mean another thing that’s on the other side of the spectrum. depth in yourself is something you create and decide and realize in your own time.
okay, so how do these two concept collide?
i mentioned earlier that my definition of depth is a concept that has meaning and/or multiple meanings. so, what if i found it meaningful – to me – to enjoy a superficial act or thing? (example: aesthetics or social media) *mic drop* i don’t find that thing or act superficial anymore because i made it meaningful. it has meaning to me, and i made it have depth to me. (however it still may seem like a superficial thing to others.)
i still don’t completely understand how or why these associations of shallowness and the items on my list (plus other i didn’t mention) came to be, but i no longer find these attributes to be completely negative, nor do i find shallowness to be as bad as i thought it was at the beginning of writing this post. for example, MEAN GIRLS has generally negative connotations on fashion and popularity and the like; but this doesn’t mean obsessively shopping for clothes or makeup or, in our case, books is a bad thing. if you find meaning in growing your social media following or taking photos that are “so tumblr” then do that. go do you, and ignore those who say or think otherwise.
“We rarely find a depth by looking inside of ourselves for it. Depth is found in what we can learn from the people and things around us. Everyone, everything, has a story, Gia. When you learn those stories, you learn experiences that fill you up, that expand your understanding. You add layers to your soul.”
– Kasie West, THE FILL-IN BOYFRIEND
i don’t think it’s really truly possible for someone to be 100% superficial. (if there is a person that is like that, i’d hardly think this person is even a human being anymore.) we all have depth in our own unique ways. books taught me to look at things from multiple POVs and perspectives. the person you may find “fake” probably isn’t all that you think he/she is. it’s also good to note that other people’s morals and thoughts and definitions may not match yours and THAT’S OKAY. for example, i know for a fact that donald trump and i think on very different wavelengths. he can go on doing his own thing as long as that thing doesn’t affect me. (in which case, him running for president and possibly changing the country of america is VERY BAD and that’s when i get all prickly.)
My main thoughts on this are that everyone is a deep person in some way, and while some “”superficial”” behaviors might be unhealthy, like obsessing over likes/followers (I feel there is a difference between wanting to grow your following/have online friends/have a good amount of people appreciate your art and wanting 5 gazillion followers) as long as you’re happy and not hurting anyone, you should be able to do what ever you want and not be judged for it. Whether that’s buying books or taking pretty pictures or spending time cooking food that will look good on your insta feed.
I think in a way, everyone is superficial and shallow – it’s just in our human nature. I think everyone is a very deep and sentimental person – I don’t think anyone is exactly as they seem, boring or only caring about their appearances! Saying that, I think everyone cares about the way they look (not just physical appearance, but their whole vibes/aesthetic type thing), so in a way everyone has elements of being superficial. As long as you’re happy doing what you like – that’s the most important thing! 😀
Denise | The Bibliolater
Eeep, I love this post and I 100% agree with that Kaise West quote. I honestly think every human has depth and I don’t know if you know of the Humans of New York guy? You probably do because doesn’t everyone?! hehe. But I LOVE how he takes photos of just anyone and everyone and they aLWAYS have a story. And it proves, every. single. person. has. a. story. Ergo how can they be shallow? I think some people CAN be selfish and oblivious, of course. And they can let the ugly in their life rule. But if a person cares about not being shallow, than I’m pretty sure they won’t be. Also: I totally like how you said it’s okay to care about pretty things and all that. I HATE how it’s seen as shallow to like things like romancey books or pink or pretty things or glitter. Like. No. That’s just horrible thinking and needs to stop.
Okay so basically I’m rambling on about nothing. xD But your post was perfect and I totally love what you said!
I think that the fact that you are aware that its possible to be superficial or lacking depth in character means that you aren’t. I worry about this issue all the time, and also about many other things, but I realized that a superficial person wouldn’t think such deep thoughts. I would say don’t worry too much but then I’m a hypocrite. So keep worrying, it just means your a human being <3
I believe that us humans are highly complicated and have many layers and I don’t think it’s possible for a person to exist as completely shallow as I think we all have depth. There’s going to be something that the media has labelled as “superficial” that we probably care about – like I do care about having a pretty Instagram page and I love pink, girly things to wear or cute things for my room and perhaps that does make me shallow, but at the same I don’t think it does because if there are things that bring us happiness and things that we care about and it’s not the main focus my life, perhaps it’s okay? Like, I’ve always viewed shallow as someone who is super focused on looks and money and that’s all they ever think about and talk about and they couldn’t be bothered with anything else? But perhaps they have an interesting hobby or something they love doing that doesn’t revolve around that and even if it does, if it brings them joy and they don’t judge others based on their appearances and material possessions surely it’s okay? I’m not actually sure, it’s a hard thing to define!
I’m so glad that you made this post. Whenever I, myself, or anyone else gets called ‘shallow’ and ‘superficial’ for enjoying things like make up, fashion and get criticised for how hard I work on how my instagram looks and that each row matches and looks the best it can, I am filled with an uncontrollable rage. I don’t think that it’s a negative thing for someone to enjoy the way that something looks and to get a kick out of having bomb-ass eyeliner. I don’t think it’s an awful thing for someone to go to an art gallery and want to enjoy the way the art looks without feeling the need to disect every stroke and colour. Just because that someone likes these things doesn’t mean that they don’t lack ‘depth’. Every human being comes with their personality and are extremely complicated people. I don’t think anyone is ’empty-headed’ and I think it’s extremely damaging that people use the words shallow and superficial to describe people, forcing women in particular to shy away from and hide the things that they love because it’s not ‘deep’. Great post, Xandra! Loved it <3
This is such an interesting post! I think its possible for people to be both shallow and deep – the amount that people are shallow/deep really varies though! I never really thought about this before..thanks for sharing!! 😀
I think calling someone superficial is very unjust. I’m pretty sure it all has something to do with what people consider “Normal”. However, the whole concept is a complete contradiction because if you happen to be someone who likes to engage in things like makeup and social media people will often call you an air head or “Basic” and those who they believe have “depth” they call them artistic or creative. However, in the same instance a person who wears makeup and likes girly things can be seen as creative or “Normal” due to standards set forth by society and someone who prefers not to engage in those things are seen as “weird” or “Socially Awkward” by the opposite position of those same exact standards. I honestly believe everyone has depth and a creative streak. Everyone just prefers different kinds of creativity. There’s not one makeup artist that does their makeup “Exactly” the same. And each person who has a vast social media following has it for different reasons. Someone may have a fashion and beauty blog, yet like to write poetry in their free time. Another person may have a poetry blog, and do makeup in their free time. Secondly, you can’t predict whether or not a person is superficial based on their social media, especially if you don’t know them personally. Of course, if you aren’t interested in makeup or clothes you would think a beauty/fashion blog is boring. That doesn’t mean the person is boring or “Superficial” it just means you have opposing interests and people need to learn to accept that not everyone is the same and even if someone likes the same things it doesn’t mean they are the same person or “Superficial”